(1) eliminated LJdrama psychopaths, especially jameth
(2) eliminated people who hadn't been around long or were not permanent members
(3) eliminated people who are mainly about fanfic, set off my creep alarm, or had lots of memecrap
That left imc, jette, and fuzzface00, none of whom have a chance. Since legomymalfoy is the most plausible opposition to jameth and seems to be decent other than the fanfic thing, I dropped fuzzface00 in her favor. (I'm letting different pieces of ronebofh's sound advice cancel out in this case, I suppose.)
As it stands, legomymalfoy is leading jameth in first-place votes, but looks likely to lose by a nose in the runoff. I strongly recommend a first-place vote for legomymalfoy.